Mistrial declared in murder trial involving man who was beaten to death, dismembered

SAN ANTONIO – A judge has declared a mistrial in a grisly murder case involving a man who was beaten to death with a baseball bat and whose body was dismembered and burned on a barbecue grill.

A jury deliberated for four days in the murder trial of 34-year-old Gabriel Moreno, but they could not reach a verdict. Moreno is among three people accused in the killing of Jose Luis Menchaca, 35.

Recommended Videos



Prosecutors said the murder was in retaliation for a drug deal.

San Antonio Police Department Officer Enrique Serrano testified that on Oct. 6, 2014, he and Detective Barton Borgens had a search warrant for a home in the 400 block of Hillwood Drive.

Serrano said that, when he and Borgens were checking a room, they noticed a detached garage in the back.

"I did smell something like a rotting flesh smell," Serrano said. "And that kind of alarmed me right away."

Serrano and Borgens testified they found the dismembered body of Menchaca in the detached garage.

CONTINUING COVERAGE ON KSAT.COM

Witness in murder trial: ‘If I didn't do anything, I would have ended up just like that guy' 

Man on trial for fatally beating, dismembering victim


About the Authors

Paul Venema is a courthouse reporter for KSAT with more than 25 years experience in the role.

Recommended Videos