New this week: Arcade Fire, 'Hatching,' Three Mile Island
This weekโs new entertainment releases include a new album from Arcade Fire, a documentary about Sheryl Crow that's described as an โintimate story of song and sacrificeโ and a four-part documentary about the Three Mile Island nuclear disaster.
Ignore the hype of Republicans threatening to โbreak awayโ over Trump
Anti-Trump Republicans get lots of media attention. That doesnโt mean they are relevant within the Republican party โIt is great that at least some former prominent Republicans are willing to stand up to Trump and for liberal democracy. But they are not serious competitors to the current Trumpian Republican party.โ Photograph: Chip Somodevilla/Getty Images โOver 100 Republicans, including former officials, threaten to splitโ from the Republican party, the New York Times declared on Tuesday. The next day the Washington Post upped the ante, headlining that the 100 Republicans were vowing โcivil warโ; the columnist Jennifer Rubin proclaimed the beginning of โthe stampede away from the GOPโ. Sounds exciting, but what has really happened? On Thursday, a group of some 150 former Republicans published โA Call for American Renewalโ, a manifesto with the stated aim of โbuilding a common sense coalition for Americaโ. The call itself reads mostly like the US constitution but with a distinct anti-Trump undertone. While the former president is never named, the manifesto warns against โforces of conspiracy, division, and despotismโ, opposes โthe employment of fear-mongering, conspiracism, and falsehoodsโ, and rejects โpopulism and illiberalismโ. It emphasizes the importance of the constitutional order, rule of law, and pluralism, while implicitly supporting immigration and explicitly celebrating โour diverse nationโ. So far, so good; but is this anodyne statement worth all the hype? Active office-holders, with power and relevance, are conspicuously absent from the signatories The documentโs signatories include many of the usual suspects of the Never-Trump right, including people associated with the Lincoln Project, like George Conway and Jennifer Horn. It also includes a lot of โformersโ: the former US representative Charlie Dent, the former secretary of transportation Mary Peters, the former governor Tom Ridge, and the former Republican National Committee chairman Michael Steele. But while these former office-holders express support for current Republican โrebelsโ like Liz Cheney and Mitt Romney, people such as Cheney and Romney themselves โ active office-holders, with power and relevance - are conspicuously absent from the signatories. I doubt they will go much further than a non-committal positive reference, when asked or pushed by journalists. For all the media spin about โinfluential Republicansโ or โRepublican leadersโ, none of the 150 signatories currently holds a significant position within the Republican party. In fact, the vast majority are people past their political career or who never were politicians. Many of them are probably better known to Democratic voters than Republican ones. During the Trump presidency, figures such as Max Boot and Michael Steele became liberalsโ favorite โRepublicansโ largely by featuring primarily in liberal media. This is probably why this manifesto is vague about the concrete actions its signatories hope to achieve. Despite hints and recent media speculation, the document makes no explicit call for a third party. In fact, one gets the sense that the organizers are internally divided over strategy โ and, for that reason, leaving all options open. Under the subheading โWhatโs the Call?โ, the document reads: โThatโs why we believe in pushing for the Republican Party to rededicate itself to founding ideals โ or else hasten the creation of an alternative.โ In essence, the whole manifesto is a real-world extension of the largely online Lincoln Project. Like the Lincoln Project, it offers a psychologically reassuring but ultimately questionable narrative frame for anti-Trump Republicans: the โsoulโ of the Republican party, which has been stolen or crushed by Trump and his wannabes, is at stake, and honorable Republicans must restore it. This is grounded in an elitist view of the Grand Old Party that rests on very loose empirical and historical grounds. As Iโve argued many times before, Trump did not hijack the party, at least not in ideological terms. In fact, for several decades the views of the Republican base had much more in common with Trump than with the signatories of this manifesto. That empirical fact will not change, no matter how hard the Lincoln Project and Never-Trump Republicans try to whitewash the Republican past โ a whitewashing the liberal media happily amplifies. This is the Republican party of an imagined past, harkening to a moderate, noble era that never really existed Evan McMullin, who gained some media prominence by running as an independent candidate against Trump in 2016 โ he won a whopping 0.54% of the vote โ seems to at least acknowledge the current reality. In an interview with Fox News, he estimated that just โa fourth to a third of the partyโ wants a new direction. He added, rather optimistically: โObviously thatโs still a minority of the party but itโs a significant number.โ Even assuming that all these people want to move the party in the same direction as the signatories of the โCall for American Renewalโ, a fourth to a third of Republicans would be a mere sliver of the general population. While this would be more than enough to start a new party in the proportional electoral systems common in other countries, it is, under the United Statesโ two-party system, nowhere near enough to challenge the Republican party, let alone the Democratic party. Donโt get me wrong. It is great that at least some former prominent Republicans are willing to stand up to Trump and for liberal democracy. But this initiative is not a serious competitor to the current Trumpian Republican party and it will not be the Republican party of the future. It does not even reflect the Republican Party of the past. Instead, it is the Republican party of an imagined past, harkening to a moderate, noble era that never really existed. Amplifying the anti-Trump Republicansโ message uncritically, as many liberal media and politicians are doing, will not make them more relevant within the Republican party. However, it might help them further whitewash their own pasts as well as that of the Republican party. Cas Mudde is Stanley Wade Shelton UGAF professor of international affairs at the University of Georgia, the author of The Far Right Today (2019), and host of the podcast Radikaal. He is a Guardian US columnist
news.yahoo.comLin Woodโs plan to take over SC GOP fails, Drew McKissick wins another term
Lin Woodโs attempt to sway enough delegates to make him the next SC GOP chairman over incumbent Drew McKissick largely failed Saturday, though the pro-Trump attorney won the majority of delegates in two of the stateโs more conservative strongholds.
news.yahoo.comCan โNever Trumpโ Republicans gain party control โ or is it a lost cause?
As Liz Cheneyโs defiance turns her into one of the movementโs leaders some insist the party was their home long before Trump while others say itโs time to move on Liz Cheney went down swinging, telling reporters: โI will do everything I can to ensure the former president never again gets anywhere near the Oval Office.โ Photograph: Evelyn Hockstein/Reuters Sixteen minutes and out. The purging of Liz Cheney from Republican leadership in the House of Representatives did not even go to a secret ballot. Instead a voice vote was all it took to confirm the partyโs capitulation to Donald Trump and his โbig lieโ about a stolen election. But Cheney went down swinging, vowing to reporters on Capitol Hill: โI will do everything I can to ensure that the former president never again gets anywhere near the Oval Office,โ then using a high-profile TV interview to say of would-be challengers for her seat in Wyoming: โBring it on.โ The public defiance instantly turned Cheney into one of the leaders of the โNever Trumpโ movement of disaffected Republicans. But it also raised strategic questions over the future direction of that movement and whether it can still regain control of the party โ or should now abandon it as a lost cause. Some insist that the party of Abraham Lincoln and Ronald Reagan was their home long before Trumpโs populist-fantasist invasion and they will fight to drive him out. Others believe that it is time to abandon ship and their future lies as independents or Democrats or even, perhaps, in a breakaway party. โWeโre torn,โ said Joe Walsh, a former congressman from Illinois. โI left the Republican party a year ago. Liz Cheney isnโt there yet. [Congressman] Adam Kinzinger, who I know well, isnโt there yet. They want to still try to reform and save the Republican party; I donโt think it can be saved. โSo thereโs a split in the Never Trump world and most Never Trumpers still agree with Liz Cheney and Adam Kinzinger: letโs try to reform the party from within. I just donโt think itโs reformable. They still harbour ideas that the Republican party can be wrestled away from Trump; it canโt be.โ Liz Cheney speaks to reporters after she was removed from her leadership role at the US Capitol on 12 May. Photograph: Kevin Dietsch/Getty Images Walsh, who mounted a long-shot challenge to Trump for the Republican nomination last year, believes that a third party is now the only solution. โWeโre at a weird moment in American history where, because the Republican party has become a cult, thereโs an opportunity to start something new. I think eventually thatโs where everybodyโs going to get to.โ On Thursday a coalition of more than 150 anti-Trump Republicans started a โpolitical movementโ urging the party to turn its back on extremism and lies. Members of A Call for American Renewal include lawyer George Conway, husband of former White House counselor Kellyanne Conway, and Anthony Scaramucci, ex-White House communications director, as well as 27 former members of the House. The group stopped short of proposing a new party โ for now. Co-organiser Evan McMullin, who ran for president as an independent in Utah in 2016, said: โWe definitely donโt rule it out but our preference is to reform the Republican party, not necessarily from within. I think most of us believe that the only way to reform the Republican party at this point is to act independently of it. โIt means that we will support good Republicans who are upholding the rule of law and defending and promoting truth and the constitution, but weโll also support viable independents where they exist. If we have to support a unifying Democrat in order to defeat an extremist Republican, weโre going to do that. If itโs Senator Mark Kelly in Arizona running for re-election against extremist Kelli Ward, then weโre going to be for Captain Mark Kelly.โ McMullin, a former CIA operations officer, added: โI think in this next cycle weโll have people who will run under our banner, people who are in office now, people who are capable of mounting credible campaigns for public office. We will invite all to associate with our principles regardless of their party registration and to run as a part of this effort.โ Adam Kinzinger during a House foreign affairs committee hearing. Photograph: Reuters Other initiatives in the Never Trump universe include the Lincoln Project, Principles First, the Republican Accountability Project and the Bulwark website. Kinzinger, who with Cheney was among 10 House Republicans to vote for Trumpโs impeachment after the 6 January insurrection at the US Capitol, launched a group called Country First to recruit and back anti-Trump Republican candidates. Cheney herself now has a platform guaranteed by her family name (her father was George W Bushโs vice-president, Dick Cheney) and looks set to be a more prominent voice than retired senators such as Bob Corker and Jeff Flake. She is reportedly planning more travel and media interviews and a political operation to support candidates who share her contempt for Trumpโs false claims of election fraud. Larry Sabato, director of the Center for Politics at the University of Virginia, said: โLiz Cheney has positioned herself to be a prominent spokesperson for the old style Republican but also a very conservative party that does not kneel before an authoritarian, which is what the others are doing. โShe deserves the position that she has has just earned. Now, thatโs not to say sheโs going to be elected president: sheโs pretty far to the right. But how can you not admire her for sacrificing the power she has now and maybe her seat?โ I think most of us believe that the only way to reform the Republican party at this point is to act independently of it Evan McMullin There are some signs that Trumpโs sway over the party is not what it was. His favourability rating among Republicans in December was 91%, with 74% holding a very favourable view, an Economist/YouGov poll found. This month the same survey showed him at 78% favourability, with 58% very favourable. But congressional Republicans appear to have concluded they cannot fight next yearโs midterm elections without him. Kevin Madden, a former adviser to Mitt Romney, now a senator for Utah and outspoken Trump critic, is in no doubt that a long haul lies ahead for Never Trumpers. โWhat is the plan to mobilise and grow that movement and is that best done inside the party or outside the party?โ he asked. โWhat is the calendar of action on that? โAnybody who thinks that this is going to be waged between now and the midterms or now and 2024 is probably being very unrealistic. The more realistic scenario is that, if Liz Cheney is to be believed about her dedication in this respect, today is the first day of what is probably a decades-long battle for the direction of the party.โ A breakaway remains unlikely with the odds stacked against anyone trying to shake up Americaโs two-party system. Competing with Democrats and Republicansโ vast fundraising machines would be daunting. In the first-past-the-post electoral system, a third party would struggle to convince people that their vote would be not be wasted in hundreds of districts. Madden, who became an independent last year and wrote in the name of Lynne Cheney, mother of Liz, on his presidential election ballot, added: โThe work of building the infrastructure to compete across 50 different states or 435 different congressional districts? That is a monumental undertaking.โ
news.yahoo.comWarren Trailing Biden, Sanders in NH, New NBC10 Boston/Franklin Pierce/Boston Herald Poll Shows
Senator Elizabeth Warren (D-MA) speaks at a campaign rally at Keene State College in Keene, New Hampshire, September 25, 2019. Elizabeth Warren has fallen into third place in New Hampshire with just one month to go until the New Hampshire primary, according to a new NBC10 Boston/Franklin Pierce University/Boston Herald poll. The poll, released Monday, has Joe Biden in first place at 26%, followed by Bernie Sanders at 22% and Warren at 18%. The poll also found that among Republican voters, President Donald Trump's approval rating appears to be dropping slightly. The percentage of Republican voters who would cast a ballot for Trump remains high, at 79%.
cnbc.com