62ºF

Best Pizza in San Antonio 2018

Here are the Top 24 Best Pizza Places in San Antonio So Far

photo

SAN ANTONIO – There’s no shortage of tacos here in San Antonio, and there's also no shortage of great pizza joints.

Through a rigorous blind taste test that rated the presentation, crust, sauce, cheese and mouthfeel of each pizza - the top 24 pizza places in San Antonio have been determined.

Over 30 different KSAT 12 employees graded each pizza without knowing who made it. The scores came from an average and are not based on one person's opinion.

The restaurants were selected by SA Live viewers during a Facebook Live response video to my original top 5 pizza list.

We will continue to rate more pizza places through the same blind taste test and update this list to create the most comprehensive pizza rating list in the Alamo City.

Here are the Top 24 Best Pizza Places in San Antonio so far- 

-------------------------

#24 - FIGLIOS - 18816 FM2252, San Antonio, TX 78266

PRESENTATION

CRUST

SAUCE

CHEESE

MOUTHFEEL

OVERALL

2.5

2.5

2.5

2

2.5

2.4

 

#23 - FLORIO'S - 7701 Broadway St, San Antonio, TX 78209

PRESENTATION

CRUST

SAUCE

CHEESE

MOUTHFEEL

OVERALL

3.25

3.5

3

3.375

2.3

3.085

 

#22 - HALFTIME PIZZA - Bandera Rd #104, San Antonio, TX 78238

PRESENTATION

CRUST

SAUCE

CHEESE

MOUTHFEEL

OVERALL

3.2

3.2

2.4

3.3

3.6

3.14

 

#21 - MOD PIZZA - 1435 N Loop 1604 W, San Antonio, TX 78258

PRESENTATION

CRUST

SAUCE

CHEESE

MOUTHFEEL

OVERALL

3.665

2.25

3

3.75

3.5

3.233

 

#20 - QUICKY WOOD FIRED PIZZA - 8620 Fredericksburg Rd, San Antonio, TX 78240

PRESENTATION

CRUST

SAUCE

CHEESE

MOUTHFEEL

OVERALL

4.115

2.715

3.07

3.29

3.265

3.291

 

#19 - 1000 DEGREES PIZZA SALAD WINGS - 11224 Huebner Rd Suite 206, San Antonio, TX 78230

PRESENTATION

CRUST

SAUCE

CHEESE

MOUTHFEEL

OVERALL

3.715

3.785

2.57

3.215

3.355

3.328

 

#18 - MELLOW MUSHROOM - 115 N Loop 1604 W # 2100, San Antonio, TX 78232

PRESENTATION

CRUST

SAUCE

CHEESE

MOUTHFEEL

OVERALL

4.085

3.335

3.085

3.415

2.915

3.367

 

#17 - BIG SLICE - 4310 Vance Jackson Rd, San Antonio, TX 78230

PRESENTATION

CRUST

SAUCE

CHEESE

MOUTHFEEL

OVERALL

2.875

3.5

2.875

3.5

4.125

3.375

 

#16 - PIZZA CLASSICS - 3440 N St Mary's St, San Antonio, TX 78215

PRESENTATION

CRUST

SAUCE

CHEESE

MOUTHFEEL

OVERALL

4

3.5

2

3.5

4

3.4

 

#15 - DECO PIZZERIA - 1815 Fredericksburg Rd, San Antonio, TX 78201

PRESENTATION

CRUST

SAUCE

CHEESE

MOUTHFEEL

OVERALL

4

3.415

2.915

3.75

3.25

3.466

 

#14 - BOB & TIMMY'S ON WHEELS - FOOD TRUCK

PRESENTATION

CRUST

SAUCE

CHEESE

MOUTHFEEL

OVERALL

3.75

3.445

3.445

3.875

3

3.503

 

#13 - 46TH ST PIZZA - 12730 W IH 10, San Antonio, TX 78230

PRESENTATION

CRUST

SAUCE

CHEESE

MOUTHFEEL

OVERALL

4.125

3.125

3.875

3.125

3.375

3.525

 

#12 - ALAMO PIZZA - 3938 S Zarzamora St, San Antonio, TX 78225

PRESENTATION

CRUST

SAUCE

CHEESE

MOUTHFEEL

OVERALL

4.1

3.5

3.8

3.2

3.1

3.54

 

#11 - PAPA JOHN'S - 6435 San Pedro Ave, San Antonio, TX 78216

PRESENTATION

CRUST

SAUCE

CHEESE

MOUTHFEEL

OVERALL

4

3.75

3.25

3.25

3.75

3.6

 

#10 - WISEGUYS - 2895 Thousand Oaks, San Antonio, TX 78232

PRESENTATION

CRUST

SAUCE

CHEESE

MOUTHFEEL

OVERALL

4.3

2.5

3.4

3.8

4

3.6

 

#9 - CAPPARELLI'S - 226 W Bitters Rd #118, San Antonio, TX 78216

PRESENTATION

CRUST

SAUCE

CHEESE

MOUTHFEEL

OVERALL

3.3

3.7

3.2

3.8

4.4

3.68

 

#8 - MAAR'S PIZZA AND MORE - 14218 Nacogdoches Rd, San Antonio, TX 78247

PRESENTATION

CRUST

SAUCE

CHEESE

MOUTHFEEL

OVERALL

4.5

4

2

4

4

3.7

 

#7 - SO BRO PIZZA CO - 1915 Broadway, San Antonio, TX 78215

PRESENTATION

CRUST

SAUCE

CHEESE

MOUTHFEEL

OVERALL

4.15

3.56

3.835

3.665

3.5

3.742

 

#6 - GRIMALDI'S - 330 E Basse Rd #101, San Antonio, TX 78209

PRESENTATION

CRUST

SAUCE

CHEESE

MOUTHFEEL

OVERALL

4.1

3.2

4.2

3.5

4

3.8

 

#5 - LITTLE ITALY - 824 Afterglow St, San Antonio, TX 78216

PRESENTATION

CRUST

SAUCE

CHEESE

MOUTHFEEL

OVERALL

4.25

3.5

3.585

3.585

4.165

3.815

 

#4 - CHUCK E. CHEESE - 238 SW Military Dr, San Antonio, TX 78221

PRESENTATION

CRUST

SAUCE

CHEESE

MOUTHFEEL

OVERALL

3.685

4.215

3.69

4.285

4.285

4.032

 

#3 - MAIN STREET PIZZA - 1906 N Main Ave, San Antonio, TX 78212

PRESENTATION

CRUST

SAUCE

CHEESE

MOUTHFEEL

OVERALL

3.915

4.585

4.165

4.335

3.915

4.183

 

#2 - CHICAGO'S PIZZA #1 - 5525 Blanco Rd, San Antonio, Texas 78216

PRESENTATION

CRUST

SAUCE

CHEESE

MOUTHFEEL

OVERALL

3.915

4.585

4.165

4.335

3.915

4.183


 

#1 - MIA MARCO'S PIZZA - 5016 FM1518, Selma, TX 78154

PRESENTATION

CRUST

SAUCE

CHEESE

MOUTHFEEL

OVERALL

5

4.5

4.65

4.75

4.9

4.76


About the Author: