‘I’ve never done any of this’: A Texas parent reluctantly dives into a school district’s battle over masks

After the Comal Independent School District decided to lift its mask mandate, a mother took on a new role

Parents were sharply divided at a recent Comal Independent School District board meeting to discuss requiring masks in schools. Credit: Bekah McNeel/The 74 Million
Parents were sharply divided at a recent Comal Independent School District board meeting to discuss requiring masks in schools. Credit: Bekah McNeel/The 74 Million (The 74 Million)

Editor’s note: This story was produced and published by The 74, a nonprofit news organization covering education. It originally appeared in the Texas Tribune.

Olivia Weisinger, never a particularly political person, found herself outside the Comal Independent School District board meeting in New Braunfels late last month, rallying parents, students and teachers to voice their anger over the school board’s decision to eliminate the district’s mask mandate.

“I’ve never done any of this,” Weisinger said in a quiet voice with a tired edge.

Before the pandemic, her eldest was happily enrolled in a Comal ISD elementary school, with three younger siblings in line behind him. Now, after a long year at odds with the district over its handling of COVID-19 policies for its 25,000 students, she’s home-schooling her son while filing grievances with the Texas Education Agency, organizing protests and making videos challenging board members’ statements.

The pandemic, along with the economic and humanitarian crises it has created, has led many people to unlikely places. As they have risen to the occasion — feeding hungry kids, signing neighbors up for vaccines, holding public officials accountable — ordinary citizens have stepped into unofficial public life like never before. Weisinger, too, has found herself in a new role: activist.

Olivia Weisinger found herself at odds with Comal ISD over the district’s handling of COVID-19 policies. Credit: Courtesy of Olivia Weisinger (Courtesy of Olivia Weisinger)

Weisinger and her growing band of parents have battled the board not just about safety but even more about accountability for the seven-member board. To make her point, she self-produced a video to fact check claims made by trustee Marty Bartlett during the March 9 board meeting, when he voted with the majority to lift the mask mandate.

Packed rooms are rare during the pandemic, but the March 25 Comal ISD board meeting was just that. A center aisle divided over 100 parents, teachers and students who had come to testify on the district’s decision to lift its mask mandate.

On one side of the aisle, masks were scarce. Those parents carried professionally printed signs that read “Kids Need Smiles” and “My Student My Choice.” On the other side, masked parents and students carried homemade signs that said things like “Love Thy Neighbor, Wear A Mask” and “Schools are Supposed to Protect Kids.”

During the pandemic, the center aisle has come to represent a seemingly unbridgeable divide between politics and science, and between personal freedom and community responsibility. In Comal County, it now divides those who feel their school district’s governing body is speaking for them, and those who feel they have been betrayed.

Weisinger started a Facebook group, Open Comal County Schools Safely, in August to show the board that parents wanted more caution as schools reopened. She offered to help the district write grants for more air filtration and outdoor classroom spaces. No one was interested, she said. “It was very apparent what you’re seeing now. They weren’t taking COVID seriously.”

As the school year went on, concerns quieted. With a mask mandate and social distancing protocols in place, schools have proved safe. Huge outbreaks have been few, and case numbers in most schools remain lower than in the general population. In-person learning has been a boon to kids who have it, and remote learning has proven to be inadequate and taxing for many children.

Then, on March 2, Gov. Greg Abbott announced that the state’s mask mandate would end a week later, on March 10. The night before the state order lifted, the Comal ISD board voted 5-2 to lift the district’s mandate as well — even though neighboring districts like New Braunfels ISD and Northside ISD, and North East ISD kept theirs in place.

Some parents implored the board to listen to science, while others thanked them for dropping the mandate. Some cited Centers for Disease Control and Prevention guidelines; others claimed that COVID-19 has been overblown to increase government control. Some referenced a survey conducted by Weisinger’s group. Others questioned the validity of the survey because it was disseminated by a pro-mask Facebook group.

The 74 Million reached out to multiple members of the Comal ISD school board for comment. None replied.

Since the district did not survey parents on the issue, as New Braunfels ISD did, Weisinger’s group decided to conduct its own survey of parents and staff, and found similar results.

The survey went out broadly, Weisinger said, with paper copies and QR codes delivered to families without reliable internet access. Of the 724 respondents, 82% wanted to see the mask mandate continue. Support for a mask mandate was highest in the city of New Braunfels and lowest in the rural areas of the county.

Some of the respondents to Weisinger’s survey shared beliefs that masks are both dangerous and tools of government control, she said. But the numbers were small.

“This division here is a much smaller faction than it feels like,” she said.

That may be true, but they have the board on their side.

Weisinger’s survey showed the majority was with her, but that doesn’t translate to an angry mob. On the whole, Comal ISD parent Susan Ostrand said, “people just aren’t that upset about it.”

Open Comal County Schools Safely organized a stay-home protest, encouraging families to keep their students home last Tuesday, the day fourth and seventh graders took state standardized tests. Participation was small.

It was indicative of another sentiment in the district: Many would prefer to keep the masks. But fewer are bothered enough to challenge their friends, neighbors and teachers who are not wearing masks.

Even parents who were ambivalent about masks say that the board could have done a better job considering the needs and perspectives of parents when they lifted the mandate.

Those who did not want to send their children to school with unmasked classmates had about 12 hours to figure out a plan, said Comal ISD parent Chrissy Dyer. She’s OK with the new policy, she said, but knows some working parents were scrambling. “It just wasn’t fair, to me, to do that to those parents.”

That disregard is felt by many, Weisinger said, and is why the resistance mounted by her group isn’t going away. Parents reached out to The 74 Million expressing frustration over how the board has handled their concerns involving racist incidents, special education services and remote learning for bilingual students.

People of color felt their concerns were minimized after school board President David Drastata referred to COVID-19 as the “China virus,” which sparked conversation about how racist slurs among students had also been written off as “profanity.” In the district’s push to reopen schools, special education and bilingual services have been substandard, parents said.

Some of these concerns have come through to Weisinger as well, and she’s helping the families figure out what legal recourse they have with the Texas Education Agency. Figuring out how and where to file complaints and grievances has taken up a lot of time, and she had a hard time finding a lawyer familiar with the Texas Education Code.

She’s committed to continuing, though, because there doesn’t seem to be another way for parents in Comal County to have their concerns taken seriously — those related to the pandemic and beyond, she said.

“This is so much deeper,” Weisinger said, “than COVID and masks.”

The 74Million.org is a nonprofit, nonpartisan media organization focused on America’s schools, education policy and 74 million children.