Man pleads guilty to fatally shooting supervisor, gets sentenced to 35 years in prison Michael Montoya killed Paul Butler at home renovation site in March 2022
Michael Montoya, 20, charged with murder (KSAT)
SAN ANTONIO – A man was sentenced to 35 years in prison Thursday after pleading guilty to fatally shooting his construction supervisor at a home they were renovating.
Michael Montoya, 20, was charged with murder in connection with the shooting death of Paul Butler, 58 .
According to the Bexar County District Attorney’s Office, Montoya approached Butler from behind and shot him multiple times at a home where they were working in the 900 block of Lamar Street on March 12, 2022. Butler died at the scene.
Montoya was a working with his stepfather, and Butler was their supervisor, the DA’s Office said.
Montoya must serve half of his sentence before being eligible for parole.
Also on KSAT.com: Copyright 2023 by KSAT - All rights reserved.
How to protect your pets during cold weather in South Texas ▶ 2:11
How to protect your pets during cold weather in South Texas
Kerrville landowner plans monument to honor volunteers who aided during deadly July 4 floods ▶ 1:48
Kerrville landowner plans monument to honor volunteers who aided during deadly July 4 floods
Woman arrested, accused of fatally shooting man in west Bexar County, sheriff says ▶ 1:51
Woman arrested, accused of fatally shooting man in west Bexar County, sheriff says
From Hill Country flooding to Bexar County wildfires, here are the Top 5 weather events of 2025 ▶ 2:16
From Hill Country flooding to Bexar County wildfires, here are the Top 5 weather events of 2025
US Army veteran from Texas credits wilderness therapy for helping adjust to civilian life ▶ 0:55
US Army veteran from Texas credits wilderness therapy for helping adjust to civilian life
Pope Leo’s first Christmas brings a powerful message ▶ 1:16
Pope Leo’s first Christmas brings a powerful message
Erica Hernandez talked to Fluffy about his special relationship with San Antonio. ▶ 1:39
Erica Hernandez talked to Fluffy about his special relationship with San Antonio.
FBI warns of ‘modern-day terrorism’ as Texas-born extremist group targets youth online ▶ 1:41
FBI warns of ‘modern-day terrorism’ as Texas-born extremist group targets youth online
Kerrville landowner plans monument to honor volunteers who aided during deadly July 4 floods ▶ 1:48
Kerrville landowner plans monument to honor volunteers who aided during deadly July 4 floods
Bystander rescues woman trapped after plane crash in Galveston ▶ 0:51
Bystander rescues woman trapped after plane crash in Galveston
Here's where letters to Santa go every Christmas ▶ 1:36
Here's where letters to Santa go every Christmas
TxDOT begins construction on multi-year US Highway 90 expansion project ▶ 1:21
TxDOT begins construction on multi-year US Highway 90 expansion project
Bexar County's Military and Veteran Services Department director placed on leave ▶ 1:30
Bexar County's Military and Veteran Services Department director placed on leave
Caught on camera: Shootout between man, BCSO deputies leaves neighborhood shocked ▶ 1:57
Caught on camera: Shootout between man, BCSO deputies leaves neighborhood shocked
San Antonio police urge reporting of minor porch thefts ▶ 1:18
San Antonio police urge reporting of minor porch thefts
Shoplifter charged with attempted murder after pointing gun at officer ▶ 1:04
Shoplifter charged with attempted murder after pointing gun at officer
Woman becomes first wheelchair user to travel to space ▶ 0:45
Woman becomes first wheelchair user to travel to space
Gibson Costume Shop, a 100-year-old San Antonio staple, to begin liquidation sales in January ▶ 1:06
Gibson Costume Shop, a 100-year-old San Antonio staple, to begin liquidation sales in January
2 deputies fatally shoot man after he fires at them during domestic disturbance call, BCSO says ▶ 0:58
2 deputies fatally shoot man after he fires at them during domestic disturbance call, BCSO says
What parents can do to help children stay safe online ▶ 0:56
What parents can do to help children stay safe online
Any dog can be ‘dangerous’ 🐾 ▶ 0:57
Any dog can be ‘dangerous’ 🐾
What to know about holiday travel as AAA projects new record ▶ 0:53
What to know about holiday travel as AAA projects new record
Steele High School student conductor reimagines 'Joy to the World' ▶ 1:51
Steele High School student conductor reimagines 'Joy to the World'
Service members traveling through San Antonio International for the holidays ▶ 1:08
Service members traveling through San Antonio International for the holidays
Salvation Army helps thousands of San Antonio children through Angel Tree program ▶ 0:56
Salvation Army helps thousands of San Antonio children through Angel Tree program
Previous photo Next photo