Man pleads guilty to fatally shooting supervisor, gets sentenced to 35 years in prison Michael Montoya killed Paul Butler at home renovation site in March 2022
Michael Montoya, 20, charged with murder (KSAT)
SAN ANTONIO – A man was sentenced to 35 years in prison Thursday after pleading guilty to fatally shooting his construction supervisor at a home they were renovating.
Michael Montoya, 20, was charged with murder in connection with the shooting death of Paul Butler, 58 .
According to the Bexar County District Attorney’s Office, Montoya approached Butler from behind and shot him multiple times at a home where they were working in the 900 block of Lamar Street on March 12, 2022. Butler died at the scene.
Montoya was a working with his stepfather, and Butler was their supervisor, the DA’s Office said.
Montoya must serve half of his sentence before being eligible for parole.
Also on KSAT.com: Copyright 2023 by KSAT - All rights reserved.
Castle Hills police department says the armed suspect shot this morning has died ▶ 0:26
Castle Hills police department says the armed suspect shot this morning has died
How to find accurate TSA wait times at airports around the country ▶ 1:27
How to find accurate TSA wait times at airports around the country
Records show New Braunfels ISD pulling, restricting more books than it has publicly listed ▶ 2:13
Records show New Braunfels ISD pulling, restricting more books than it has publicly listed
Residents hope to stave off light pollution caused by rapid growth of nearby San Antonio ▶ 1:15
Residents hope to stave off light pollution caused by rapid growth of nearby San Antonio
74 year old woman hit crossing South General McMullen ▶ 1:36
74 year old woman hit crossing South General McMullen
Lake Placid and Lake McQueeney are coming back after sitting empty ▶ 2:19
Lake Placid and Lake McQueeney are coming back after sitting empty
New emissions test could cost Bexar County vehicle owners ▶ 0:37
New emissions test could cost Bexar County vehicle owners
Victims’ families sound off on Bexar County DA after accused double murderer gets 50-year sentence ▶ 0:40
Victims’ families sound off on Bexar County DA after accused double murderer gets 50-year sentence
San Antonio attorney admits stealing over half a million dollars from children's inheritance. ▶ 0:33
San Antonio attorney admits stealing over half a million dollars from children's inheritance.
Watch 'Dangerous Lessons' Monday at 9 pm ▶ 0:36
Watch 'Dangerous Lessons' Monday at 9 pm
Arrest made in deadly car racing accident ▶ 1:30
Arrest made in deadly car racing accident
Spurs respond after viral video at game sparks backlash ▶ 0:52
Spurs respond after viral video at game sparks backlash
Is the 'smokable' hemp market about to be set ablaze? ▶ 1:40
Is the 'smokable' hemp market about to be set ablaze?
Reuniting items found along the Guadalupe River after the deadly floods ▶ 1:59
Reuniting items found along the Guadalupe River after the deadly floods
Week one of Christopher Preciado trial wraps up ▶ 1:06
Week one of Christopher Preciado trial wraps up
SA airport reports short TSA wait ▶ 1:22
SA airport reports short TSA wait
Summer Savings Ideas in SA ▶ 1:45
Summer Savings Ideas in SA
Should the city rename César Chávez Blvd? ▶ 0:29
Should the city rename César Chávez Blvd?
Shuttle driver rescues toddler from a busy road ▶ 1:00
Shuttle driver rescues toddler from a busy road
Man dies by suicide in police custody ▶ 0:35
Man dies by suicide in police custody
Day 3: Erica Hernandez recaps evidence shown ▶ 1:05
Day 3: Erica Hernandez recaps evidence shown
San Antonio César Chávez march organizers, foundation disbands amid sexual abuse allegations ▶ 1:02
San Antonio César Chávez march organizers, foundation disbands amid sexual abuse allegations
SAPD says 12-year-old killed in a street racing crash ▶ 1:32
SAPD says 12-year-old killed in a street racing crash
2026 César E. Chávez March for Justice cancelled ▶ 2:10
2026 César E. Chávez March for Justice cancelled
Christopher Preciado Capital Murder Trial Day 2 ▶ 1:02
Christopher Preciado Capital Murder Trial Day 2
Previous photo Next photo