Woman sentenced to 25 years in prison in connection with murder case Whitney Caraway, 34, fatally stabbed 35-year-old Amanda Newton
Whitney Caraway booking photo (Bexar County Jail)
SAN ANTONIO – A 34-year-old woman was sentenced to 25 years in prison on Friday after fatally stabbing a woman at a North Side apartment complex in 2023.
A Bexar County grand jury found Whitney Caraway guilty in the murder of Amanda Newton, 35.
Prosecutors said Caraway stabbed Newton multiple times during an altercation. Caraway and Newton had both allegedly been romantically involved with the same man.
Police said Newton and a friend confronted Caraway around 1:30 a.m. on May 22, 2023, at the Hamilton Place Apartments in the 1650 block of Jackson Keller Road, which led to a fight between Caraway and Newton.
During the altercation, Newton was stabbed 11 times. Several witnesses were there when the fight happened, and Newton died at the scene. Caraway fled in a vehicle, police said.
San Antonio police officers arrived to find Newton on the ground in the parking lot, bleeding. She was pronounced dead at the scene.
Read also Copyright 2023 by KSAT - All rights reserved.
About the Author Spencer Heath headshot
Spencer Heath is a Digital Journalist at KSAT. Spencer graduated from the University of Texas at Austin, where he studied Radio-Television-Film. He’s worked as a journalist in San Antonio since June of 2022.
Outside the newsroom, he enjoys watching movies and spending time with family.
Sights and sounds: USC, TCU fans tailgate before Valero Alamo Bowl in San Antonio ▶ 1:13
Sights and sounds: USC, TCU fans tailgate before Valero Alamo Bowl in San Antonio
What you need to know about Alamo Bowl traffic ▶ 0:37
What you need to know about Alamo Bowl traffic
River Walk visitors share safety concerns as downtown prepares for busy events ▶ 1:17
River Walk visitors share safety concerns as downtown prepares for busy events
BCSO shares video of pedestrian believed to be missing 19-year-old woman ▶ 0:28
BCSO shares video of pedestrian believed to be missing 19-year-old woman
Family of missing 19-year-old continues search efforts nearly one week after her disappearance ▶ 0:27
Family of missing 19-year-old continues search efforts nearly one week after her disappearance
How a free University Health program seeks to help manage patient medication intake ▶ 1:25
How a free University Health program seeks to help manage patient medication intake
Here’s how to recycle Christmas trees, lights in San Antonio ▶ 1:14
Here’s how to recycle Christmas trees, lights in San Antonio
Deputy who brought fast food to inmate, officer charged with DWI top list of law enforcement arrests ▶ 3:15
Deputy who brought fast food to inmate, officer charged with DWI top list of law enforcement arrests
How to protect your pets during cold weather in South Texas ▶ 2:11
How to protect your pets during cold weather in South Texas
Kerrville landowner plans monument to honor volunteers who aided during deadly July 4 floods ▶ 1:48
Kerrville landowner plans monument to honor volunteers who aided during deadly July 4 floods
Woman arrested, accused of fatally shooting man in west Bexar County, sheriff says ▶ 1:51
Woman arrested, accused of fatally shooting man in west Bexar County, sheriff says
From Hill Country flooding to Bexar County wildfires, here are the Top 5 weather events of 2025 ▶ 2:16
From Hill Country flooding to Bexar County wildfires, here are the Top 5 weather events of 2025
US Army veteran from Texas credits wilderness therapy for helping adjust to civilian life ▶ 0:55
US Army veteran from Texas credits wilderness therapy for helping adjust to civilian life
FBI warns of ‘modern-day terrorism’ as Texas-born extremist group targets youth online ▶ 1:41
FBI warns of ‘modern-day terrorism’ as Texas-born extremist group targets youth online
Kerrville landowner plans monument to honor volunteers who aided during deadly July 4 floods ▶ 1:48
Kerrville landowner plans monument to honor volunteers who aided during deadly July 4 floods
Bystander rescues woman trapped after plane crash in Galveston ▶ 0:51
Bystander rescues woman trapped after plane crash in Galveston
TxDOT begins construction on multi-year US Highway 90 expansion project ▶ 1:21
TxDOT begins construction on multi-year US Highway 90 expansion project
Bexar County's Military and Veteran Services Department director placed on leave ▶ 1:30
Bexar County's Military and Veteran Services Department director placed on leave
Gibson Costume Shop, a 100-year-old San Antonio staple, to begin liquidation sales in January ▶ 1:06
Gibson Costume Shop, a 100-year-old San Antonio staple, to begin liquidation sales in January
What parents can do to help children stay safe online ▶ 0:56
What parents can do to help children stay safe online
Any dog can be ‘dangerous’ 🐾 ▶ 0:57
Any dog can be ‘dangerous’ 🐾
Steele High School student conductor reimagines 'Joy to the World' ▶ 1:51
Steele High School student conductor reimagines 'Joy to the World'
Scams targeting San Antonio seniors on the rise, SAPD says ▶ 0:50
Scams targeting San Antonio seniors on the rise, SAPD says
Outgoing North East ISD superintendent discusses timing of departure, district’s challenges ahead ▶ 1:14
Outgoing North East ISD superintendent discusses timing of departure, district’s challenges ahead
🦍 Congo Falls gorilla exhibit at San Antonio Zoo to open this weekend ▶ 1:47
🦍 Congo Falls gorilla exhibit at San Antonio Zoo to open this weekend
Previous photo Next photo