ROMA, Texas – Unable to meet with her students in person because of the pandemic, Taylor Lifka, an advanced English teacher at Roma High School, set out to personalize and add warmth to her virtual classroom space.
She displayed a collage of posters, just like the ones in her real classroom: one read “Black Lives Matter,” another included a rainbow flag and a third had a phrase written in Spanish that highlights solidarity between Black and brown people. On the digital chalk board, she asked students to put their name and preferred pronoun in the chatbox. Then, she posted a screenshot of her classroom on her social media.
On Sunday, one day before she was supposed to welcome her students back virtually for the first day of class, she was told by a school official to take down the signs. She refused. A few hours later, she was placed on leave.
"My assistant principal told me, 'Please take the posters down.' I guess once that happened I knew that it might be a rocky road, but considering being put on leave? I never really thought that that was going to be their first step,” she said in an interview with The Texas Tribune.
Roma school officials said that several parents and community members filed complaints to the district about the Black Lives Matter and LGBTQ posters. She was told she could return Tuesday and would be allowed to retain the posters as long as they did “not come to overly disrupt or detract from the educational process or the learning environment.”
“This action was not intended to reflect any form of punishment or admonishment towards Ms. Lifka but was purely driven by a need to review the circumstances and come to a sound resolution for all persons involved,” the Roma Independent School District said in a statement Wednesday.
The English teacher said she won’t return until the district commits to tangible change and supporting “antiracist policies and tolerance in our classrooms.” Lifka specifically asked the district to provide additional training and clarify guidance for staff regarding inclusion.
“If I just reenter the classroom without any further discussion or action of how is this going to change in our community, then what was all this for?” Lifka said.
Lifka said “this all sort of exploded” after a screenshot of the picture she posted on her personal social media account was shared in pro-President Donald Trump Facebook groups and amplified by Marian Knowlton, a Republican running for the District 31 state House seat.
In a since-deleted Facebook post, Knowlton said the education system was “radicalizing” students and referred to the posters as an example of “leftist indoctrination.” In a separate statement Wednesday morning, Knowlton said she deleted her original post about the virtual classroom — which she said had more than 10,000 comments — after getting harassed online.
Thousands of parents, students and community members have expressed outrage at the school district for punishing Lifka. An online petition asking for Lifka’s reinstatement amassed more than 23,000 signatures as of Wednesday evening.
“Even though [the district] stated that it's not a reprimand … depriving a teacher of teaching — their actual job — I think that's a reprimand in itself,” said Andrik Garcia, a senior at Roma High School who took Lifka’s English class last year.
The Roma High School Student Council, who Lifka advises, released a public statement Tuesday calling her suspension “unjust.” The group said teachers shouldn’t be punished for creating a safe and inclusive environment for students and said it’s not a political statement to stand against sexism, homophobia and racism.
“This is not bias. It’s equality,” the statement reads.
Lifka said the support she's received has been encouraging.
"To see what my kids have done with their voice over this is just unspeakable. That's the teaching moment,” Lifka said. “Don't ever doubt that your voice matters because there is power in the people and there is the power to your voice and what you have to say.”
Lifka said while she was told she could put the signs back up, she was also warned by school officials that she or the school district could be sued because of them. Scott Schneider, an Austin lawyer who specializes in education, said the school district was likely employing a scare tactic to discourage her from displaying the posters.
“I can’t for the life of me think of what a claim would be against her. I can’t think of anything,” he said. “I think that’s baseless.”
Sign up for The Brief, The Texas Tribune’s daily newsletter that keeps readers up to speed on the most essential Texas news.